“We were always waiting for something to happen.”
-The Gaslight Anthem, “Great Expectations”
Something has happened. The Gaslight Anthem has gone from a promising young rock band to the Next Big Thing. They have gone from playing small clubs in their native New Jersey to playing “The ’59 Sound” with Bruce Springsteen in England. The greatest of expectations have been heaped upon American Slang, and it largely lives up to the hype.
It’s hard to listen to American Slang without thinking of Bruce Springsteen’s breakthrough, Born to Run. Both records are about leaving your comfort zone and moving to bigger and better things. But while Born to Run is about leaving to escape the small town, American Slang is more optimistic. The Gaslight Anthem have left New Jersey not because of extenuating circumstances, but because they want to see what is beyond their world.
The title track will draw some comparisons to “Great Expectations,” but there are several key differences. In “Great Expectations,” Fallon was restless because he didn’t know how to get out of his situation. He’s restless in “American Slang,” because he’s getting ready to move on. He lays it on the all on the line in the first couple verses, “I seem to be coming out of my skin/Look what you’ve forgotten here/the bandages won’t keep me in.” Instead of sounding urgent, the guitars ring out. He spent the first two records preparing for this moment and now he’s finally ready.
Now that the band is moving away from their Jersey roots, the punk influence of the first two records is slightly toned down. Alex Rosamilia’s guitar playing is still driving, but it jangles rather than crackles. Instead of bashing the drums, Ben Horowitz playing is more reserved and tasteful. The streamlined sound puts more of an emphasis on the choruses, which are even bigger than The ’59 Sound. “The Boxer” begins with the chorus chanted over sparse drum beats, anticipating audience participation
The band was listening to a lot of vintage soul while making this album and it shows. Fallon’s singing is smoother, with a hint of gospel. On “The Queen of Lower Chelsea,” the music is mixed in the back, with the emphasis on the vocals. The lyrics are hopeful, but there is a hint of sadness when he sings, “nothing is free/not even me.”
But maybe it isn’t sadness, but wistfulness. The Gaslight Anthem is in a precarious position. Two years ago they were still four kids from Jersey, psyched to get a cover story on AP. Now they are regularly featured in Rolling Stone. Some fans may balk at the sound of the new record, complaining that it’s no longer punk rock. The guitars don’t buzz like they did on Sink or Swim, but the heart of this band is still a mile wide. The sound is bigger and more polished, but The Gaslight Anthem hasn’t forgotten who brought them to the dance.




